Circular Knitting Workshop

Well, all my ideas about what I was going to knit came to naught, because I’ve been asked to review a book, Margaret Radcliffe’s Circular Knitting Workshop.

As soon as I got into it I went and emptied the stash basket to find something to experiment on. This is – and I am saying this without any bias; I know I freelance with publishers but there is absolutely no link between me and Storey Press – a fantastic book.

One thing – it is emphatically not a book of patterns using circular knitting. It is exactly what it says on the cover: a workshop. And what a workshop.

(Plus – shhh – a lot of the information is useful for flat knitting, too.)

Now, I hardly ever knit in the round. Yes, I use ‘circular’ needles a lot, but I hardly ever join the fabric up. I’m a flat knitter. Er, only metaphorically, ahem. But Margaret Ratcliff has got me going, and now I can’t stop. That’s one of the consequences, of course – as she says early on, addressing the question of why you should consider knitting in the round, ‘some knitters love the meditative flow of knitting in the round – it goes on and on without interruptions for turning and switching hands.’ Or interruptions which effectively tell you that you need to put the knitting down occasionally.

And that’s difficult. There are so many ideas and techniques and tips that you want to try out, solutions to problems that have had you stumped for ages. Well, that had me stumped anyway (doing anything that looks good on DPNs).

Take casting on, for example. There are details of thirteen different ways for achieving different effects while specifically knitting in the round (the basic five are covered briefly, and in more detail in an appendix), including one I’d not come across before, the Channel Islands cast-on. It also addresses the question of deciding which side is the right side, and it was at this point that I emptied the stash onto the floor of the spare room.

I always cast on in the same way, as taught by my mother, and as she was taught by her mother, and so on, back into Celtic myth, legend and – no doubt – the Great Hunger. I like to think of it as the ‘Stroppy Irish’ cast-on in honour of its origins. It’s a thumb cast-on with a long tail, but like no cast-on I’ve ever seen illustrated in a book, and I’ve never seen anyone else cast on in quite the same way (you can do it almost one-handed; ideal for when you’re at the peats or beating up the landlord). It gives you a lovely bound-off edge with just the right flexibility, but it looks best on the ‘wrong’ side, so I always start a piece of knitting with a wrong-side row and turn what should be the wrong side into the right side. It suddenly struck me that I wouldn’t have to do that if I were knitting in the round.

 And I didn’t.

(Mind you, I did have to cast on twice after the tip came off one of the interchangeable cords because I’d not fastened it on securely.)

Anyway, enough of me. This book is a real workshop, rather like spending a weekend retreat mastering a skill completely. The first part is technical, and the second is devoted to projects, often small – they can be sized up – which allow you to test the skills learned in the first half. Take, for instance, this shawl (the Double Double Trellis Shawl):

It uses a closed centre cast-on, and interesting variations in stitch pattern which will cause variations in tension. And because of those changes, the placement of the increases is dictated by the shawl measurement rather than the row count. I am intrigued, and I want to get stuck in and see if it works. I also want to try it because Radcliffe suggests an alternative to this pesky DPNs when starting the centre and I’d like to see if that works as well: using two circular needles. (I know I could do the Magic Loop, but I’d like to have a go something else, as long as it’s not DPNs.) It looks fiddly, but I have to give it a go. Eventually.

Throughout the book, problems are addressed and tackled. Here, for instance, the question of whether the shawl could be worked outside in is raised – and demolished, but that’s OK because the next project is one worked form the perimeter to the middle. And the question of weaving in the ends in colour knitting is raised: be careful, because the tendency is to weave them in as you knit, and that means they all end up in the same direction, and in the same area, making it bulkier – and weaker at the start as they all pull away from the end of a round. But my hands aren’t really ready for that yet.

Back to something less ambitious, perhaps. I find the illustrations very clear and useful, though it’s just as well I like turquoise…

And the small things are tackled too. Making thumbs, for instance, or the three different ways of avoiding that sneaky little jog you get when you join your circle right at the start (wish I’d read that bit earlier, but I can deal with my bijou jogette later).

And then there’s the part I’m not altogether sure I will explore in depth – converting flat patterns to circular. Margaret Radcliffe isn’t completely dogmatic; there are some circumstances in which flat knitting is appropriate and both methods have their advantages and disadvantages. But it is useful to be able to do something like colour work in the round even if the pattern you want to use has been written for flat knitting, and I’m sure I will end up consulting this section. At some point.

At some point. For now I just have to stop knitting before I wreck my hands again.

That’s the trouble with circular knitting; it’s not so much meditative as addictive. Oh, and it’s a bag, or it will be (in about five minutes, on previous evidence). My larger version of the booga bag in Noro Kureyon, to be felted.

In retrospect, the Circular Knitting Workshop is perfect for me. It intrigues me intellectually and also in terms of my skills; it inspires me to try new things and it panders to my addiction. Boy, does it pander to my addiction. Move away from the needles. Move away from the needles. Move away from the needles…



15 thoughts on “Circular Knitting Workshop

    1. kate Post author

      I found it really interesting, and I’m almost a circular-knitting virgin. There’s so much info in it, and at all sorts of levels. The tips are excellent…

  1. Harriet

    I much prefer knitting in the round, despite it’s addictiveness and this sounds like a must have but can I really justify yet another knitting book? Although if this ‘summer’ weather continues I won’t be doing anything else but sewing and knitting! Looking forward to seeing that bag finished. How are the hands holding up?

    1. kate Post author

      Well, I thought that, but this is much more than just another book (mind you, I seem to apply that ‘logic’ a lot). Oh dear, I’m casting myself as some sort of enabler here!

      I’ve already used several of her suggestions in the bag, which presently looks like half a strange duvet cover in stripy wool. It will felt down. It will felt down. It WILL felt down. Now all I have to do is knit about 2-3 metres of i-cord and felt that too. Amazingly the hands are coping well….

  2. karibu57

    Totally agree with you…it’s a fab book and even for me (an avid circular knitter) there were so many new things to try out.

    1. kate Post author

      Oh, I am glad to know that – as I don’t often knit circularly (is that even a word?), I did wonder if it would appeal to the more expert among us – and you can’t get more expert than you!

    1. kate Post author

      I keep going back to it – I’m sure you’ll find it useful, and certainly interestinghueqhr -sorry about that, a sheep just looked in at me through the kitchen window. How the heck did that get in to the garden?

      (Stand still, Doris, and I’ll shear you). Must dash…

      1. kate Post author

        Phew. Sheep retrieved. Well, heading back home. NB: This is Welsh village, not city centre. Sometimes stereotypes are rooted in reality.

        Postie leave garden gate open, someone evidently also leave hill gate open. Sheep wander down hill to small car park, a fave place, who knows why. Sheep sneak peek inside prohibited place, aka my garden. No, not looking for fleece back (like woolly version of Cravendale ad), suspect looking for lunch. Owner chase sheep out. Sheep shoot back up hill like guilty schoolchildren.

    1. kate Post author

      I took it along to our Spin Sunday yesterday, and it went down very well there too. Definitely worth a look (but if you have a deep antipathy to turquoise, you may need filters. It’s the abiding unifying colour, and happily my favourite)…

  3. elizabethm

    I love knitting in the round and I love the sound of this book because I am very much a beginner, but I must not start! It is summer. Summer is gardening time. All my wools are put away and my hands are filthy and I have to save knitting for winter to make it bearable. Must not, must not, get my wool out.

    1. kate Post author

      It’s a very good book………
      And I should be spending all these long evenings in the garden, working away, but when it’s pretending to be November outside………

      Sorry. Don’t let me interrupt you!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s